TEAMS | SCORES | SCHEDULES | TRANSACTIONS | HISTORY | RULES
home
STATS
standings
batting leaders
fielding leaders
pitching leaders
team totals - batting
team totals - fielding
team totals - pitching
free agent batters
free agent pitchers
TEAMS
allentown mules
arkansas falcons
blue ridge bombers
brick city batmen
charlotte webbs
durham bulls
el paso chihuahuas
empire city trojans
hillsborough hitmen
hoboken cutters
hopatcong floating fish
livingston lords of swing
matthew's mighty men
san francisco experience
sard. city straphangers
vancouver iron fist
SEASON
transactions
injuries
picks lost/added
league schedule
ARTICLES
this week in dmb
did you know?
milestones
number crunch
preseason
press box
prospecting
real world
rookie watch
trade talk
HISTORIC
all-star game
awards
career
dream season
hall of fame
playoffs
records
COMMUNITY
forum
facebook
league quiz
email the commish
VITAL LINKS
league rules
rotoworld
espn
diamond mind
baseball reference








Wednesday, January 25, 2012

POINT-COUNTERPOINT: John Olerud, Hall of Fame?

NO, HE'S NOT: A Good Player, But Not A Great One
By Phil Plantier

John OlerudJohn Olerud was a mainstay of the early 2000s Arkansas Golden Falcons. A four-time All-Star and both the All-Star and World Series MVPs in 1999, he hit .300 with an amazing .403 career OBP. He won two World Series rings and reached the post-season eight times in his 12-year career.

But was he truly a Hall of Famer? While he was in the league for a long time, he only had in 5,185 career ABs -- he was a platoon player in his first and last season, missed almost all of 1997, and of course 1995 was the strike year. As a result, you won't find him on the career leaderboard in any category.

Most dramatically, Olerud hit just 148 HRs -- 1 HR for every 35 AB. His lack of power (career .457 SLG) dropped his career OPS to .860 despite his amazing OBP. (Not to whine, but I hit one every 13 AB and had an .829 OPS, but I only got one season in the DMBL.) You want power from your corners, and Olerud couldn't supply it.

There have been a lot of players with career OPS's in the mid-800s -- Harold Baines (.846), Ellis Burks (.850), Ken Caminiti (.846), Tim Salmon (.869), Mo Vaughn (.842) -- who were passed over by the voters.

In a few years there will be guys like Brian Giles (.886), Ryan Klesko (.891), and Bernie Williams (.881) on the ballot. If you let in Olerud, I guess they are all Hall of Famers, too?

YES, HE IS: Fuck you, Phil Plantier
By John Olerud

Jonah Hill knows I'm a Hall of Famer!I think spending all that time in Triple-A must have made you soft in the head. (Maybe you should've worn a helmet all the time like I did.) You don't seem to understand that a career .403 OBP means that I was one of the best players in baseball for a very long time. I didn't hit a lot of home runs, but that's why we had Barry Bonds and Juan Gonzalez. My job was to get on base, and I was one of the best in league history at doing that.

Among all players eligible for the Hall of Fame, I rank 7th in on-base percentage. Seventh! Plantier, didn't you read Moneyball? Or at least see the movie? OBP is where it's at, kid.

Oh and P.S., hell yeah Klesko will be a Hall of Famer. Dude could rake.




What do you think? Let us know by casting your ballot for the Hall of Fame!

No comments :